Cat Litter Faceoff: Extra Select vs. Catsan 28L

Today, we will be comparing two popular cat litters, ‘Extra Select Cat Litter’ and ‘Catsan 28L 2-pack’. Our goal is to provide you with a clear and balanced comparison to help you make an informed decision based on the specific needs of your feline friend. Let’s explore the key features, advantages, and potential drawbacks of each option to assist you in choosing the best litter for your beloved cat.

Ultimate Freshness

Extra Select Cat Litter
Extra Select Cat Litter
£22.02
as of 1 November 2024 03:19
BUY NOW
Amazon.co.uk
8.2

Experience a cleaner and fresher litter box with Extra Select Premium Hygiene Cat Litter in a convenient 10 Litre size. This low dust, non-clumping litter provides odor control, easy scooping, and hygienic features that keep your cat happy and your home smelling fresh.

Odor Control

Catsan 28L 2-pack
Catsan 28L 2-pack
£20.99 £22.54 
as of 1 November 2024 03:19
BUY NOW
Amazon.co.uk
9.3

Keep your cat’s litter tray dry and hygienic with CATSAN Hygiene Cat Litter. Made of natural materials, it absorbs odors and locks in liquid for reliable odor control without added fragrances. Perfect for sensitive cats of all ages, including kittens, it’s convenient and easy to use.

Extra Select Cat Litter

Pet Type
Cats

Odour Control
Yes

Size
10 Litre

Weight
4.1 kg

Clumping
Non-Clumping

Catsan 28L 2-pack

Pet Type
Cats

Odour Control
Yes

Size
28 Litre

Weight
1.5 kg

Clumping
Non-Clumping

Extra Select Cat Litter

Pluses
  • Good at absorbing moisture and odors
  • Easy to sift and clumps well
  • Cats seem to like it

Catsan 28L 2-pack

Pluses
  • Controls odors effectively
  • Does not stick to cat’s paws
  • Lasts longer, providing good value for money

Extra Select Cat Litter

Drawbacks
  • It does not control odor as effectively as other brands such as Tesco or C brand
  • The litter may leave a lingering smell of cat urine that can be unpleasant

Catsan 28L 2-pack

Feature comparison chart

Extra Select Cat Litter vs Catsan 28L 2-pack
Extra Select Cat Litter
VS
Catsan 28L 2-pack
Quantity
10 Litres
VS
28 Litres (2 packs of 14 Litres)
Odor Control
Excellent odor control
VS
Highly effective odor neutralization
Absorbency
Absorbs liquids quickly
VS
Superior liquid absorption
Composition
Clumping clay formula
VS
Quartz granules
Dust Level
Low dust emission
VS
Minimal dust production
Fragrance
Light, pleasant scent
VS
Unscented option available

Extra Select Premium Hygiene Cat Litter

  • USPs:
    • Clumping clay formula for easy waste removal.
    • Excellent odor control keeping the environment fresh.
  • Pros:
    • Absorbs liquids quickly, reducing tracking.
  • Cons:
    • Light fragrance may not suit all cats.
  • Use-case:
    • Ideal for multi-cat households due to its odor control.

Catsan Hygiene Cat Litter

  • USPs:
    • Quartz granules excel in liquid absorption.
    • Low dust production for cleaner air quality.
  • Pros:
    • Highly effective odor neutralization.
  • Cons:
    • Unscented option, which may not appeal to all users.
  • Use-case:
    • Perfect for sensitive cats due to low dust emission.

In this comparison, the Catsan Hygiene Cat Litter emerges as the winner for its superior liquid absorption and excellent odor neutralization. However, for households with multiple cats, the Extra Select Premium Hygiene Cat Litter may be more suitable due to its clumping feature and light fragrance. Choose Catsan for efficiency, or Extra Select for multi-cat homes seeking odor control.

In conclusion, if you value superior liquid absorption and odor control, Catsan is the way to go. For those with multiple cats and a need for clumping convenience, Extra Select is a great option. Make your choice based on your specific priorities and cat’s preferences, ensuring a clean and fresh environment for your feline friend.

Alternative Cat Litter Options

Comparing Cat Litter Products

When choosing the right cat litter for your feline companion, it’s important to consider various factors to ensure you provide the best environment for your cat. Here are some general guidelines and key factors to consider when comparing products in the Cat Litter category:

Types of Cat Litter

  • Clumping Litter
  • Non-Clumping Litter
  • Silica Gel Crystals

Key Factors to Consider

  • Odor Control
  • Absorbency
  • Dust Level
  • Tracking
  • Eco-Friendly Options

Extra Select Cat Litter

  • Clumping litter
  • Strong odor control
  • High absorbency
  • Low dust level
  • Made from natural ingredients
  • Eco-friendly option

Catsan 28L 2-pack

  • Non-clumping litter
  • Good odor control
  • Moderate absorbency
  • Some dust present
  • Trusted brand
  • Cost-effective option

Remember to consider your cat’s preferences and your household needs when choosing the right cat litter. It’s essential to prioritize your cat’s comfort and health when making your decision.

Cat Litter FAQ

How does the odor control of Extra Select compare to Catsan 28L?

When comparing the odor control of Extra Select Premium Hygiene Cat Litter (10 Litre) to Catsan Hygiene Cat Litter (28L), it’s important to note that both products are designed to help control odors in the litter box. However, the effectiveness of odor control can vary depending on individual preferences and the needs of your cat.

Extra Select Premium Hygiene Cat Litter is known for its absorbency and odor control properties, providing a fresh environment for your cat. On the other hand, Catsan Hygiene Cat Litter is also formulated to trap and neutralize odors, promoting a clean and hygienic litter box.

Ultimately, the best choice between Extra Select and Catsan will depend on your cat’s preferences and your personal experience with each product. It may be beneficial to try out both options to see which one works best for you and your feline companion.

How often should cat litter be changed?

It is recommended to change cat litter at least once a day to maintain cleanliness and odor control. By using high-quality products like the Extra Select Premium Hygiene Cat Litter or Catsan Hygiene Cat Litter, you can ensure that your cat’s litter box remains fresh and hygienic. It is important to scoop out waste regularly and top up with fresh litter as needed to keep your cat happy and healthy.

Are there any natural or eco-friendly alternatives to traditional cat litter?

Yes, there are natural and eco-friendly alternatives to traditional cat litter. Some options include litter made from recycled paper, wood shavings, corn, wheat, coconut husks, and even silica gel crystals. These alternatives are biodegradable, sustainable, and help minimize environmental impact compared to traditional clay-based litters. It’s important to check for any specific recommendations for your cat’s health and comfort when transitioning to a new litter type.

Which cat litter clumps better, Extra Select or Catsan 28L?

Both Extra Select Premium Hygiene Cat Litter and Catsan Hygiene Cat Litter are known for their clumping abilities due to their highly absorbent properties. However, based on user reviews and product comparisons, Catsan 28L tends to clump better and form firmer clumps compared to Extra Select. It is, therefore, more effective in trapping odors and making it easier to clean and maintain your cat’s litter box.

Which cat litter is more cost-effective, Extra Select or Catsan 28L?

In this comparison of Extra Select Premium Hygiene Cat Litter, 10 Litre, and Catsan Hygiene Cat Litter 28L (2x14L), Catsan 28L would be more cost-effective based on volume. While the Extra Select provides 10 liters, the Catsan offer double that at 28 liters. By choosing the Catsan option, you would get more litter for a potentially better value.

Are there any differences in tracking between Extra Select and Catsan 28L?

Yes, there are differences in tracking between Extra Select Premium Hygiene Cat Litter (10 Litre) and Catsan Hygiene Cat Litter 28L (2x14L). Extra Select cat litter is known for having less tracking compared to some other litters, including Catsan. The size and texture of the granules can play a part in tracking, and in this case, Extra Select may have an advantage in reducing the amount of litter that your cat tracks outside the litter box.

Are there any health risks associated with certain types of cat litter?

Yes, there can be health risks associated with certain types of cat litter. Some clumping litters contain sodium bentonite, which can be harmful if ingested by your pet. Dust from silica-based litters can also irritate your cat’s respiratory system. It is important to consider these factors when choosing a cat litter and to monitor your cat’s health while using any type of litter. It’s best to consult with your veterinarian to determine the safest option for your feline friend.

What is the best type of cat litter for odor control?

When it comes to odor control in cat litter, clumping litters are generally considered the most effective. Both Extra Select Premium Hygiene Cat Litter and Catsan Hygiene Cat Litter are clumping litters, making them good choices for controlling odors. The clumping action helps to trap and contain odors effectively. Remember to regularly clean out the litter box and replace the litter to maintain optimal odor control.

14 Comments
  1. I prefer Catsan 28L 2-pack because of its larger packaging size, making it more convenient for me as a cat owner with multiple cats.

  2. Thank you for sharing your experience! It’s great to hear that Extra Select worked better for you.

  3. Great comparison post! I appreciate the detailed analysis of Extra Select and Catsan 28L 2-pack.

  4. I recommend checking out PrettyLitter if you’re looking for a new cat litter option. It’s lightweight, non-clumping, and changes color to indicate potential health issues in your cat.

  5. I’ve been using Extra Select for a few months now, and it has been effective in controlling odors. However, I find it a bit too dusty compared to Catsan 28L 2-pack.

  6. I’m looking for recommendations on a cat litter that is eco-friendly and still effective. Any suggestions other than Extra Select and Catsan 28L 2-pack?

  7. Can anyone share tips on how to transition a picky cat to a new cat litter like Extra Select or Catsan 28L 2-pack?

    • Transitioning to a new cat litter can be tricky. Try mixing a small amount of the new litter with the old one gradually to help your cat adjust.

  8. I wish the pricing for Extra Select was a bit lower. Does anyone have tips on where to find discounts or coupons for cat litter products?

  9. I’ve tried both Extra Select and Catsan 28L 2-pack, and I found Extra Select to be more clumping and odor-controlling. Definitely my go-to choice now!

  10. I completely agree with the author’s assessment. Extra Select is definitely superior when it comes to clumping and odor control.

Leave a reply

Petterbuy
Logo